Skip to main content
Home / News and Insights / News / Lush brings in court to determine value of shares
28 November 2017

Lush brings in court to determine value of shares

A conflict between two director-shareholders at Lush led to a court dispute over how to value shares on a sale.

Embroiled in internal disputes, Mr Genie left the company and sought to sell his and his wife’s shares in two companies connected with Lush.

However, within the company’s articles of association, any shareholder wanting to sell their shares had to first offer them to existing shareholders at a price agreed between all parties.

After the parties failed to agree on a valuation of the shares, independent accountants stepped in. However, the parties could not agree on whether it would be best to calculate the price:

  • pro-rata: The calculation is based on their minority shareholding in the overall value of the company which is likely to give rise to a higher valuation; or
  • share premium: The calculation is based on assessing the minority shareholding individually at a discounted rate which is likely to give rise to a lower valuation.

The Court of Appeal examined the companies’ articles, noting that they directed the accountants to value the companies as a whole. The court interpreted the relationship between the two companies as being one of a quasi-partnership, and held that general contractual principles had to be applied to the articles such that the shares should be valued on a pro-rata basis.

This case demonstrates that where the court is required to intervene in shareholder disputes and matters of the company, it will adopt an objective, factual and commercial approach when assessing all the circumstances. When drafting contractual documents, clarity is vital in terms of reflecting all parties’ intentions in the wording.

Related Articles

Our Offices

London Westminster
50 Broadway, London
SW1H 0BL

Cambridge
50/60 Station Road
Cambridge
CB1 2JH

Reading, The Anchorage
34 Bridge Street Berkshire
Reading RG1 2LU

Southampton
Grosvenor House, Grosvenor Square
Southampton SO15 2BE

 

Reading, The Anchorage
34 Bridge Street Berkshire
Reading RG1 2LU

Southampton
Grosvenor House, Grosvenor Square
Southampton SO15 2BE

Follow us

  • Pay my invoice
  • Lexcel
  • CYBER ESSENTIALS PLUS

© BDB Pitmans 2020. 50 Broadway, London, SW1H 0BL - T +44 (0)345 222 9222